The Three-Tier Cheeseburger Challenge: Cheap, Aged, and Wagyu Walk Into a Kitchen

TL;DR

• Three cheeseburgers at wildly different price points: everyday smash burger, dry-aged rib eye, and full Wagyu
• Each burger gets custom sauces and cheese pairings matched to its price tier
• The verdict? No winner—they’re too different to compare, each owns its lane
• Smash burger wins everyday life, dry-aged for special occasions, Wagyu for treating yourself
• All three deliver happiness, just in completely different ways

—

▶00:01 What happens when you take comfort food and push it to three totally different extremes? Guga answers that with three cheeseburgers spanning the full price spectrum, from budget-friendly to “maybe once a year.”

Burger #1: The Smash Burger (Budget Champion)

▶00:32 Starting at the bottom of the price ladder with the cheapest ground beef available—73/27 fat ratio, because who needs lean when you’re smashing? This is the burger you make on Tuesday night when nobody’s watching.

Ingredients:

• 73/27 ground beef (cheapest available)
• 5-3 oz portions
• American cheese
• Cheapest buns ($2 for 8)
• Sauce: mayo, ketchup, yellow mustard, sweet relish

Method:

1. Form beef into 2.5-3 oz balls, place on parchment paper
2. Mix sauce ingredients together
3. Smash technique (details in video)
4. Top with American cheese
5. Assemble on budget buns

Burger #2: The Dry-Aged Rib Eye (Grown-Up Burger)

▶01:34 Now we’re getting fancy. A 35-day dry-aged rib eye becomes burger meat, because apparently some people have standards. This requires actual work—removing the pellicle (that funky outer layer), trimming connective tissue and silver skin, then grinding fresh.

Ingredients:

• 35-day dry-aged rib eye
• Provolone cheese
• Brioche buns (homemade recipe linked)
• Sauce: mayo, Worcestershire, Louisiana hot sauce, garlic powder, black pepper

Method:

1. Remove pellicle from dry-aged meat (strong flavor)
2. Trim all connective tissue and silver skin
3. Grind on lowest setting, keep meat cold throughout
4. No added fat needed—the marbling does the work
5. Mix sauce ingredients
6. Form patties, cook, top with provolone
7. Serve on brioche buns

Burger #3: The Wagyu Experience (Treat Yourself Tier)

▶03:24 Full Wagyu beef—the “Picasso of beef” with fat-to-meat ratio so perfect it literally melts in your hands while you’re trying to make patties. Work fast or you’ll be holding beef soup. This one gets a three-cheese sauce that’s basically liquid gold.

Ingredients:

• Full Wagyu beef
• Three-cheese sauce: Brie (rind on), Parmigiano-Reggiano, aged Gruyere, butter
• Burger sauce: Japanese mayo, Brazilian hot sauce (very spicy), ketchup manis (sweet soy sauce)
• Premium buns

Method:

1. Work quickly—Wagyu fat melts from hand heat alone
2. Form patties fast
3. Make cheese sauce: Melt butter on low heat, add all three cheeses, stir on medium-low until melted smooth
4. Mix burger sauce ingredients
5. Cook patties (they’ll render a lot of fat)
6. Assemble with three-cheese sauce

The Verdict

▶07:01 Guga starts with the smash burger and has a revelation: “This one changed my life.” It’s the perfect burger for every scenario—quick, easy, cheap, affordable. The classic done right.

▶08:19 The dry-aged burger delivers a “much truer taste” that screams maturity. This isn’t a kids’ meal—it’s what you order when you’re dressed nice, pairing it with wine or expensive beer. You can taste the dry-aging instantly.

▶09:32 The Wagyu burger is unmistakable from the first bite. It’s an occasion burger, an experience unto itself. But it’s expensive enough that “maybe once a year, once every six months” is the realistic play.

▶10:17 No winner declared. They’re so different you can’t pick. The smash burger owns everyday family life. The dry-aged is a unique experience. The Wagyu is for when you deserve something special. All three make anybody happy—they just operate in completely different universes.

We try hard to get the details right, but nobody’s perfect. Spot something off? Let us know